Posted by: Robert Horwitz | November 18, 2026

California Office of Tax Appeals Holds that Divisions of a Corporation Were Not a Unitary Business by Robert S. Horwitz

The California Franchise Tax Board (FTB) has frequently claimed, successfully, that a business that didn’t operate in California was unitary with a business that did operate in California. This requires the two businesses to pool their income and deductions, so they are taxed as one business. Where an out-of-state entity sells an interest in an entity it owns that does business in California, the FTB has successfully argued that the businesses are unitary, which results in the out-of-state seller being liable for income tax in California for a portion of the gain from the sale. See Appeal of Smith, 2023-OTA-069P. The OTA recently handed the FTB a loss in Appeal of Western Distributing Company, et al, 2026-OTA-467P. This blog will not focus on the OTA’s legal analysis, but upon the evidence that was presented that convinced the OTA that Western Distributing’s beverage distribution division was not unitary with its other divisions.

Click Here for Full Article

Robert S. Horwitz is a Principal at Hochman Salkin Toscher Perez P.C., former Chair of the Taxation Section, California Lawyers’ Association, a Fellow of the American College of Tax Counsel, a former Assistant United States Attorney and a former Trial Attorney, United States Department of Justice Tax Division. He represents clients throughout the United States and elsewhere involving federal and state administrative civil tax disputes and tax litigation as well as defending clients in criminal tax investigations and prosecutions. In 2022 the Tax Section of the California Lawyers Association awarded him the Joanne M. Garvey Award for lifetime achievement in and contributions to the field of tax law. 

For more information, please contact Robert Horwitz at horwitz@taxlitigator.com.


Leave a Reply

Categories